multiple axis alignment control
There seems to be a lot of posts in the forum asking how to align the 0 values of multiple y axes.
My thoughts for implementing this:
Chart level option (like alignTicks): alignBaseline: boolean (default: true)
Axis level option: baseline:(numeric) (default: 0)
By default 0 is the baseline for each axis, and by default the 0 value for each axis is aligned.
The user can set the baseline to any other set of numbers that should be aligned, or turn off alignment.
I implemented this experimentally, see http://jsfiddle.net/highcharts/jrXQe/.
One problem now is that ticks are added, but the amount of ticks is not regulated to match the tickPixelInterval. There are probably other issues as well, please feel free to comment as you find problems, and we’ll keep the demo updated.
@Lukasz Currently you can't set both, as the alignThreshold plugin overwrites the alignTicks setting. But in general, if you use a smaller tickPixelInterval, the alignment gets better because it is easier to find an axis resolution that fits both data sets: http://jsfiddle.net/highcharts/y6pbqk6q/2/
The alignTicks: false option seems to not be reflected when alignThreshold: true. http://jsfiddle.net/y6pbqk6q/1/
In the example, I would like the max value on the primary axis scale to be lower then 2500, because the max value in the data is < 1200
I've just spotted a weird behavior of this plugin, with some specific set of data.
It could make an axis display an abnormal number of decimals.
Here is my fiddle where you can notice it: http://jsfiddle.net/by1hjp9k/2/
You can comment/uncomment lignes 64 and 66 to change the value of aData and see the differences.
Any tip to fix that ? I don't want to use yAxis.labels.formatter as my axis can display greater values where decimals would not be expected to be displayed.
One thing I am noticing is that if you hide one of the series, the remaining y axis does not adjust accordingly.
If you hide both series, and then show only one, the axis is scaled appropriately. But once you show both series, and then hide one, the axis retains the scaling for the hidden series, which is counter to highcharts normal behavior.
Thanks for your response!
Altho it does not explain to me why the 'maximum' does not get rounded to the same absolute value, I'll keep it in mind. It seems this solution posted here works well enough - we can live without tickPixelnterval, and some testing did not uncover any other problems as of yet.
good work, thanks.
It's still not perfect, as it disregards the tickPixelInterval setting.
For your solution about setting min and max explicitly. The docs explains why Highcharts adds padding to your setting: http://api.highcharts.com/highcharts#yAxis.min
gents, may I ask when will this solution be completely implemented and released?
Also: it'd be a perfectly working solution if I could sync min/max per axis.
I can calculate the axis min/max in code before generation, however, highcharts often disregards the given value to be able to line up the axes. Funnily enough the algorithm does a different 'disregarding' on the max & the min values. If it was at expanded/recalculated the same way, not to different values, it'd work.
this works super fine! Thanks for your effort.
Luis Miguel commented
Ok, tested. It works.
@Luis Miguel: You need to supply a threshold. Lines don't have a threshold by default. http://jsfiddle.net/highcharts/jrXQe/5/
Luis Miguel commented
Hi, the change in the plugin (version 2013-12-02) works fine, but I detected another bug trying with different values.
For example, I used the following series:
type: 'line', data: [1129.9, 1171.5, 1106.4, 1129.2, 1144.0, 1176.0, 1135.6, 1148.5, 1216.4, 1194.1, 1195.6, 1154.4]
type: 'line', data: [29.9, -71.5, -106.4, -129.2, -144.0, -176.0, -135.6, -148.5, -216.4, -194.1, -95.6, -54.4]
type: 'line', data: [129.9, 271.5, 306.4, -29.2, 544.0, 376.0, 435.6, 348.5, 216.4, 294.1, 35.6, 354.4],
Serie 1, new. All values positive and higher than 1000
Serie 2, the same that original serie 1
Serie 3, the same that original serie 2
Whenever serie 1 is of type line, when it shows/hides serie 2 from the legend, does not align the axes.
The difference is that line series don't have a threshold by default, so you need to threshold: 0 on the line series. I've fixed this in the plugin so when no threshold is given, 0 is assumed.
We have the same problem as Luis, does not work for line and columns series in one chart.
Any fix for this ?
Hi, we have tested lines series and columns series together and I'm afraid that dual axes are not alienated.
Could you test it please?
Hello , is there any news about this feature ?
We appreciate the many votes - I'm afraid the train has left for 3.0, and we will have some catching up to do now before adding new features.
Pragnesh Patel commented
its been more than year for this issue. any chance to fix it?
J .Jetten commented
When do you expect this solution goes into production?
Phil Thompson commented
I found it odd that this was not the default. Would be great to have this as an option.
Bram Vd Eijken commented
I would absolutely love this idea. This would help a lot with my program where I have multiple y-axis each with different extremes.
Right now I have to do a dirty workaround >.>